| Player | Points |
| Bob Grether | 9 |
| Ted Grether | 7.5 |
| Mike Grether | 7 |
| Ben Grether | 6 |
| Jody Grether | 5 |
| Tim Grether | 3 |
| Trei Brundrett | 2.5 |
| Danielle Brundrett | 2 |
| Helen Grether | 2 |
| Kaitlyn Harkins | 2 |
| Theresa Grether | 2 |
| Doug Grether | 1.5 |
| Derek Grether | 1.5 |
| Kristin Harriger | 1.5 |
| Steve Grether | 1 |
| Dan Grether | 1 |
| Pam Manville | 1 |
| Rebecca Hodgkinson | 1 |
| Joe Brundrett | 1 |
| Brittany Grether | 0.5 |
| David Gagne | 0.5 |
| Rachel Campbell | 0.5 |
| Owen Grether | 0.5 |
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | Kill Champ | Park | City |
| 1985 | Mike Grether | Steve Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1986 | Doug Grether | Mike Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1987 | Derek Grether | Tim Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1988 | Dan Grether | Danielle Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1989 | Tim Grether | David Gagne | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1990 | Danielle Grether | Theresa Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1991 | Pam Manville | Doug Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1992 | Mike Grether | Danielle Brundrett Ted Grether |
N/A | Nathaniel Greene | Springfield, MO |
| 1993 | Bob Grether | Ted Grether | N/A | Arrowhead | Plano, TX |
| 1994 | Bob Grether | Ben Grether | N/A | Arrowhead | Plano, TX |
| 1995 | Ben Grether | Mike Grether | N/A | Duncan | Austin, TX |
| 1996 | Bob Grether | Helen Grether | N/A | Arrowhead | Plano, TX |
| 1997 | Ben Grether | Bob Grether | N/A | Elgin B. Robertson | Rowlette, TX |
| 1998 | Rebecca Hodgkinson | Bob Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 1999 | Ted Grether | Mike Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 2000 | Helen Grether | Bob Grether | N/A | WJ Thomas | Carrollton, TX |
| 2001 | Bob Grether | Steve Grether | N/A | Elm Fork | Pilot Point, TX |
| 2002 | Ted Grether | Mike Grether | N/A | Stacy | Austin, TX |
| 2003 | Ted Grether | Ben Grether | N/A | hidden Cove | The Colony, TX |
| 2004 | Trei Brundrett | Kristin Harriger | N/A | Stacy | Austin, TX |
| 2004B | Jody Grether | Derek Grether | N/A | Bob Woodruff | Plano, TX |
| 2005 | Kristin Harriger | Mike Grether | N/A | Elm Fork | Pilot Point, TX |
| 2006 | Mike Grether | Bob Grether | N/A | Stacy | Austin, TX |
| 2007 | Ben Grether | Helen Grether | N/A | Stude | Houston, TX |
| 2008 | Jody Grether | Ben Grether | N/A | Elm Fork | Pilot Point, TX |
| 2009 | Bob Grether | Ted Grether | N/A | Stacy | Austin, TX |
| 2010 | Mike Grether | Ben Grether | N/A | T.C. | Houston, TX |
| 2010B | Kaitlyn Harkins | Jody Grether | N/A | Bob Woodruff | Plano, TX |
| 2011 | Ted Grether | Rachell Campbell | N/A | Heritage | Sachse, TX |
| 2012 | Ben Grether | Mike Grether | N/A | T.C. Jester | Houston, TX |
| 2012B | Jody Grether | Tim Grether | N/A | Heritage | Sachse, TX |
| 2013 | Joe Brundrett | Trei Brundrett | Trei Brundrett | Zilker | Austin, TX |
| 2013B | Kaitlyn Harkins | Jody Grether | Jody Grether | Heritage | Sachse, TX |
| 2014 | Ted Grether | Brittany Grether | Ted Grether | Heritage | Sachse, TX |
| 2015 | Bob Grether | Owen Grether | Bob Grether | Zilker | Austin, TX |
| 2015B | Tim Grether | Theresa Grether | Theresa Grether | Heritage | Sachse, TX |
| City | Plays at city |
| Carrollton, TX | 10 |
| Austin, TX | 7 |
| Plano, TX | 5 |
| Sachse, TX | 5 |
| Pilot Point, TX | 3 |
| Houston, TX | 3 |
| Springfield, MO | 1 |
| Rowlette, TX | 1 |
| The Colony, TX | 1 |